“Windahl’s Wednesday does such a great job showing how the character is the product of both parents and how that’s making her into herself that I wished she had more to do.”

— Columbus Underground

 "Otterbein seems to have a storehouse of exceptional actors and actresses in this musical...rounding out the Addams clan are Windahl, Cullinane, Aubree Tally (Grandma) and Jacob Sundlie (Lurch)."

— Broadway World